I read this article by Marc Prensky about 5 years ago. It is
interesting to read it again now. Five year ago, I believed that I was a
digital native, but I am not quite sure anymore now. I would say I am still a
true digital native with an “accent” of Digital Immigrant.
Am I getting “old?” Hopefully not! Let me explain further.
I am 28 years old and grew up with downloaded music, phones
in my pocket, and “googleing” all the time and so on. According to Prensky, I
am a digital native. However, I like to ask students printing out documents
written on computers in order to edit it. I still prefer printing out research
papers to read, highlight phrases, and annotate in the margins with a real pen.
I know I can easily do such things with Adobe Reader or Preview, and save our
planet earth by cutting down the usage of paper. But still, there is something
to it that I actually can learn better with tangible objects in hand. This
could potentially make me a digital immigrant according Prensky. I wonder how could
this happen? Perhaps, from my Digital Immigrant teachers in the past…
I recently had some 12th graders work on a
project. The project requires two pages of writing on Microsoft Word and a
PowerPoint presentation including videos and pictures to introduce a notable
Chinese American. All of them did a great job, and yet they all did it
differently in their own ways. Here is how it went:
Student A on a computer: Wikipedia, YouTube, online
dictionary, Word Document, PowerPoint all open at the same time while
“Facebooking,” listening to music and texting on the phone
Student B: Started researching online on her phone because
“it’s too much work to turn on a computer” according to her. Then she wrote
down the information with a pencil on a piece of paper and started to write her
first draft by hand.
Student C: Asked me all sorts of questions regarding to the
person he wanted to research on for about 15 minutes. Then he Google everything
on the phone and came back to me sharing what he found. He wrote down few
things in his notebook AND on his phone because “I know I probably can’t find
the notebook again later on.”
Student D: Started typing Chinese characters on a desktop,
and decided to quit after 5 minutes. “This is so annoying, I cannot get this
right. I will hand-write it on my phone, send it to myself and do editing in a
Word document later.”
Student E: watched a lot of video clips related to the
person he researched on for the first 25 minutes on Youtube
What’s the point here I am trying to convey from these
observations?
I guess as a teacher and an instructional designer, it is
important to keep the followings in mind:
- provide a framework and a final goal for them to
achieve
- the step-by-step procedure won’t work because
there isn’t a certain way anymore
- Digital
natives have their own ways of doing things
-
it’s OK as long as they get it done the “right” way
- it’s NOT OK when nothing gets done, or done
in the “wrong” way (ex: plagiarism)
THEN
we interfere.